For high school students aiming to apply to STEM programs, free psychology programs, or summer research programs for teens, extracurriculars are more than a bonus, they’re a reflection of who you are outside the classroom. But while strong activities can elevate an application, poorly curated or misrepresented ones can raise red flags.
In this blog, you’ll learn about 10 common red flags in extracurricular activity lists and how to fix them, so that your profile is not only competitive but also authentic and aligned with your academic path.
Why High Schoolers Should Curate Activities with Intention
Competitive research programs and colleges don't want you to be perfect, but rather notice patterns of initiative, growth, and initiative. Whether you're shooting for an Ivy League mentorship for high school students or an interdisciplinary summer program, your activities should demonstrate your intellectual curiosity, consistency, and impact in the real world.
But students frequently overdo their resumes or fail to tell a coherent story.
1. Your List Is a Mile Wide and an Inch Deep
It’s tempting to showcase everything you’ve ever done, especially when friends are padding their Common App with 10+ clubs. But reviewers notice when your activities lack depth or direction.
How to Fix It:
Rather than cataloging every club and camp, focus on activities that demonstrate long-term dedication or passion. For instance, if you're applying to research programs in STEM, emphasize:
Multi-year involvement in robotics or coding
Summer internships in labs
Science fair projects that evolved over time
This shows your evolving understanding of a field and communicates purpose-driven commitment, which is far more impactful than scattered participation.
2. You Only List Title Roles Without Any Action
“President of Science Club” sounds great, until you realize there’s no mention of what you actually did. Leadership without substance is a common red flag.
How to Fix It:
Describe your actual impact: Did you mentor new members? Organize a STEM challenge? Run a coding workshop for middle schoolers? Show the reader what changed because of your leadership.
High school students should focus not on the position, but on the problems they solved, the people they led, and the outcomes achieved.
3. Your Activities Don’t Align with Your Academic Focus
A student applying to psychology mentorships but only listing sports or theater activities may appear undecided.
Why It’s a Red Flag:
Admissions officers may struggle to see a clear link between your stated academic goals and the extracurricular context you’ve built.
How to Fix It:
Make sure at least a few of your activities support your intended major. For psychology: include peer mentoring, mental health awareness clubs, or child development internships. For STEM: coding, robotics, environmental science campaigns. Connecting activities with your aspirations builds a more convincing and coherent narrative.
4. Overuse of Vague Phrases
Phrases like “helped organize events” or “raised awareness” don’t say much.
Why It Matters:
Generic descriptions blur your contribution and make it difficult for reviewers to visualize your initiative.
How to Fix It:
Use concrete language: "Led a 3-day mental health seminar with 100+ attendees," or "Designed and launched an app that helps students manage homework deadlines." Specifics bring your contributions to life.
5. Activities That Ended Quickly
One-time events, 3-week camps, or abandoned initiatives show a lack of follow-through.
Why It’s a Red Flag:
It implies you're collecting experiences for checkboxes rather than pursuing meaningful work.
How to Fix It:
Pair short-term experiences with evidence of longer engagement. For example, a 2-week research program is more impactful if you followed it up with an independent research project or presentation. Showing evolution from exposure to exploration to execution is key.
6. Only School-Based Roles, No Independent Work
Listing only school-led activities can suggest a lack of initiative. Research programs especially look for self-motivation.
How to Fix It:
Include independent projects: started a blog, taught yourself Python, created a podcast, conducted an experiment at home. These show authentic curiosity.
If you joined a summer program for teens and continued working on your project after it ended, make sure to mention that follow-through.
7. No Collaboration or Community Impact
A list that’s all about personal growth but doesn’t mention helping others can seem self-centered.
Why It’s a Red Flag:
Colleges and mentorship programs seek contributors, not just achievers.
How to Fix It:
Highlight teamwork, peer leadership, or volunteering. Did you tutor classmates? Start a peer support group? Help organize a fundraiser? Even solo projects can have ripple effects when shared.
8. Activities Feel Forced or Generic
If your list sounds too polished or full of resume-speak, it may feel inauthentic.
How to Fix It:
Use your real voice. Rather than "Used strategic planning to implement logistics," say "Organized weekly coding challenges for club members to stay active while learning virtually."
Make your extracurriculars reveal your personality, not your credentials.
9. No Demonstrated Growth
If all your activities show the same level of responsibility across four years, it may signal a lack of development.
How to Fix It:
Highlight progression: member → team lead → organizer → mentor. Show how you evolved and took on more responsibility.
Growth is a narrative tool, use it to show that you’re coachable, ambitious, and increasingly impactful.
10. Activities Don’t Support Your Application Narrative
A scattered list of unrelated clubs and events can confuse reviewers about your academic and personal direction.
Why It Matters:
Your application will be much stronger if your essays, recommendation letters, and activity list are all consistent.
How to Fix It:
Tell a tale. Your actions should relate to the narrative you are presenting in your application, which includes your goals, interests, and values. Any school-related activity, such as science fair projects, coding clubs, math competitions, or independent research, can be considered a STEM program for high school students. Peer counseling, mental health advocacy, and leadership in community service are further examples of interests in psychology or social advocacy.
What a Strong List Looks Like
A nicely filled-out extracurricular list may contain only 6–8 items, but each adds value. Here's a straightforward example:
Science Research Club (Founder/President, Grades 10–12): Created the club to guide students for science fairs; tutored 15 students; organized 3 school-wide symposiums.
Mental Health Podcast (Creator, Grades 11–12): Conducted interviews with psychologists and high school students on teen mental health; released 10+ episodes.
Python Projects (Independent, Grades 9-12): Created 3 public dataset visualization tools; shared on GitHub and got over 500 views.
Each activity here is personal, clear, and contributes to a larger story about academic interests and leadership.
Final Thoughts
What you participate in after school could tell much about you; you are more than a mere student. Fraser believes a well-thought-out resume may make all the difference between getting Ivy League mentorship, applying to free high school psychology programs, or finding research opportunities for the summer.
You need to take some time thinking about, editing, and reorganizing your activities to better reflect your goals. This way, you can have a more powerful application and more meaningfully spend your high school years.
Ready to Rethink Your List?
Start by asking yourself:
Which activities show true initiative?
Where have I made the biggest impact?
What connects most clearly to my academic focus?
Then make bold edits. A list that is clear, cohesive, and genuine will always be more noticeable than one that is overly polished and packed.
Remember that it's not about what you do, but how and why, whether you're preparing for a competitive summer program, applying for a mentorship, or writing your college resume.
If you are a high school student pushing yourself to stand out in college applications, RISE Research offers a unique opportunity to work one-on-one with mentors from top universities around the world.
Through personalized guidance and independent research projects that can lead to prestigious publications, RISE helps you build a standout academic profile and develop skills that set you apart. With flexible program dates and global accessibility, ambitious students can apply year-round. To learn more about eligibility, costs, and how to get started, visit RISE Research’s official website and take your college preparation to the next level!
Read More
